Encore B&W
Rather like expectant parents holding in their hands the ultrascan of their new baby and showing off the little snap to anyone prepared to humour them, I thought I’d show the cover of the 2nd edition of my Advanced Digital B&W Photography. While I completed the rewrite before Christmas and have already seen the proposed cover, it was only this morning that I wanted to see when it would be delivered. It looks like it’s May in the UK and US and afterwards in a number of translations.
When the original book was released five years ago, I’m proud to say that it notched up a few firsts. I was lucky to be writing at such an opportune time and to have distinguished some new developments which I felt would change the best way to work. So it was the first book on digital B&W:
- To cover Lightroom
- Ditto for Aperture
- Photoshop’s B&W adjustment filter
- Photoshop smart objects for a B&W workflow
This time round, it’s not as much of a turning point for us B&W workers. Instead we’re in a period where those changes have become established, Silver Efex Pro has fleshed out, and where some of the old problems of colour casts have been countered by printers with more inks or just been accepted as par for the course. I can’t see mobile apps like Nik’s Snapseed or Adobe’s Revel (ex Carousel) as much more than a way for people to gain some appreciation of B&W – healthy though that must be. So in the second edition:
- Most of the new content is Lightroom.
- A lot of new content is on Silver Efex Pro
Of course, if you do ever want to experiment with your pictures you can always hit V in Lightroom and it will show them in colour. Thankfully hitting V (or Undo) will make them look right again. Why bother with colour?







Yesterday I needed to look up some tutorials on extracting people from backgrounds in Photoshop. You usually need a variety of techniques but if you don’t know CS5′s Refine Mask/Edges take a look at these:
The pictures were corrected in Lightroom 3 but finished in Silver Efex Pro 2. They were not sent directly to SFX though. While that would be the most obvious route, it would mean that SFX would return to Lightroom a flattened TIF file with all the toning, borders and local adjustments baked in. Instead I prefer to initially send pictures to Photoshop CS5 as smart objects, and then invoke SFX. This means SFX’s adjustments are applied as smart filters, so they remain editable and I can always go back to these files and fine tune the treatment. And this fine tuning is something I often do. The other difference from before is that I no longer seem to be using the Selective Colour slider in SFX to restore the colour but instead do it in Photoshop with a copy of the image layer with its Blending Mode set to Color. It’s a close choice, but I prefer the accuracy I can get by creating a mask with tools like Select > Selective Color, Quick Selection Magic Wand, or even just the Brush, Quick Mask and blur to hide my handiwork. You can see with this example how detailed some of the masks can become.